Deployment exception with HelloWorldIPCPortlet.SAR

[rabbuhl]

I am using JBoss Portal 2.4.1-SP1. If I hot deploy HelloWorldIPCPortlet.SAR it works correctly without any errors. However, when I stop and then start JBoss Portal I the following error appears in the log file. If I stop JBoss Portal, remove HelloWorldIPCPortlet.SAR, and then start JBoss Portal again the error disappears. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Richard

--- MBeans waiting for other MBeans ---
ObjectName: portal:container=Instance
State: FAILED
Reason: org.jboss.deployment.DeploymentException: No Attribute found with name: CacheNaturalId
I Depend On:
portal:service=Hibernate,type=Instance
portal:service=PortletInvoker,type=Instance
portal:service=PortalAuthorizationManagerFactory
portal:service=AuthorizationDomainRegistry
Depends On Me:
portal:controller=Request
portal:deployer=PortalWebApp
portal:deploymentFactory=PortletApp

ObjectName: portal:container=PortalObject
State: FAILED
Reason: org.jboss.deployment.DeploymentException: No Attribute found with name: CacheNaturalId
I Depend On:
portal:service=Hibernate,type=PortalObject
portal:service=PortalAuthorizationManagerFactory
portal:service=AuthorizationDomainRegistry
portal:service=ListenerRegistry
Depends On Me:
portal:commandFactory=DefaultPortal
portal:commandFactory=PortalObject
portal:controller=Request
portal:deployer=PortalWebApp
portal:deploymentFactory=Object

ObjectName: portal:commandFactory=DefaultPortal
State: CONFIGURED
I Depend On:
portal:commandFactory=Delegating
portal:container=PortalObject
Depends On Me:
portal:controller=Request

ObjectName: portal:commandFactory=PortalObject
State: CONFIGURED
I Depend On:
portal:container=PortalObject
Depends On Me:
portal:commandFactory=Delegate,prefix=portal

ObjectName: portal:commandFactory=Delegate,prefix=portal
State: CONFIGURED
I Depend On:
portal:commandFactory=Delegating
portal:commandFactory=PortalObject

ObjectName: portal:controller=Request
State: CONFIGURED
I Depend On:
portal:service=PageService
portal:commandFactory=DefaultPortal
portal:urlFactory=Delegating
portal:service=InterceptorStack,type=Command
portal:container=PortalObject
portal:container=Instance

ObjectName: portal:deployer=PortalWebApp
State: CONFIGURED
I Depend On:
jboss.system:service=MainDeployer
portal:container=PortalObject
portal:container=Instance
portal:service=Server
Depends On Me:
portal:deploymentFactory=Object
portal:deploymentFactory=PortletApp
portal:deploymentFactory=Layout
portal:deploymentFactory=LayoutFeatures
portal:deploymentFactory=Theme
portal:deployer=Adapter

ObjectName: portal:deploymentFactory=Object
State: CONFIGURED
I Depend On:
portal:deployer=PortalWebApp
portal:container=PortalObject

ObjectName: portal:deploymentFactory=PortletApp
State: CONFIGURED
I Depend On:
portal:id=local,service=PortletInvokerRegistration
portal:deployer=PortalWebApp
portal:service=WebAppRegistry
portal:service=ServerConfig
portal:service=PortletSecurityService
portal:container=Instance

ObjectName: portal:deploymentFactory=Layout
State: CONFIGURED
I Depend On:
portal:deployer=PortalWebApp
portal:service=LayoutService

ObjectName: portal:deploymentFactory=LayoutFeatures
State: CONFIGURED
I Depend On:
portal:deployer=PortalWebApp
portal:service=LayoutService

ObjectName: portal:deploymentFactory=Theme
State: CONFIGURED
I Depend On:
portal:deployer=PortalWebApp
portal:service=ThemeService

ObjectName: portal:deployer=Adapter
State: CONFIGURED
I Depend On:
jboss.web:service=WebServer
portal:deployer=PortalWebApp

--- MBEANS THAT ARE THE ROOT CAUSE OF THE PROBLEM ---
ObjectName: portal:container=Instance
State: FAILED
Reason: org.jboss.deployment.DeploymentException: No Attribute found with name: CacheNaturalId
I Depend On:
portal:service=Hibernate,type=Instance
portal:service=PortletInvoker,type=Instance
portal:service=PortalAuthorizationManagerFactory
portal:service=AuthorizationDomainRegistry
Depends On Me:
portal:controller=Request
portal:deployer=PortalWebApp
portal:deploymentFactory=PortletApp

ObjectName: portal:container=PortalObject
State: FAILED
Reason: org.jboss.deployment.DeploymentException: No Attribute found with name: CacheNaturalId
I Depend On:
portal:service=Hibernate,type=PortalObject
portal:service=PortalAuthorizationManagerFactory
portal:service=AuthorizationDomainRegistry
portal:service=ListenerRegistry
Depends On Me:
portal:commandFactory=DefaultPortal
portal:commandFactory=PortalObject
portal:controller=Request
portal:deployer=PortalWebApp
portal:deploymentFactory=Object

[rabbuhl]

I fixed the deployment problem by changing jboss-portal.sar\META-INF\jboss-service.xml. Specifically, I commented out the attribute definition for CacheNaturalId.

Question for the JBoss Portal development team: should the attribute CacheNaturalId be defined in these mbeans?

<!-- The different containers -->
 <mbean
 code="org.jboss.portal.core.impl.model.instance.PersistentInstanceContainer"
 name="portal:container=Instance"
 xmbean-dd=""
 xmbean-code="org.jboss.portal.common.system.JBossServiceModelMBean">
 <xmbean/>
 <depends>portal:service=Hibernate,type=Instance</depends>
 <depends
 optional-attribute-name="PortletInvoker"
 proxy-type="attribute">portal:service=PortletInvoker,type=Instance</depends>
 <depends
 optional-attribute-name="PortalAuthorizationManagerFactory"
 proxy-type="attribute">portal:service=PortalAuthorizationManagerFactory</depends>
 <depends
 optional-attribute-name="AuthorizationDomainRegistry"
 proxy-type="attribute">portal:service=AuthorizationDomainRegistry</depends>
 <attribute name="SessionFactoryJNDIName">java:/portal/InstanceSessionFactory</attribute>
 <!--attribute name="CacheNaturalId">true</attribute-->
 </mbean>
 <mbean
 code="org.jboss.portal.core.impl.model.portal.PersistentPortalObjectContainer"
 name="portal:container=PortalObject"
 xmbean-dd=""
 xmbean-code="org.jboss.portal.common.system.JBossServiceModelMBean">
 <xmbean/>
 <depends>portal:service=Hibernate,type=PortalObject</depends>
 <depends
 optional-attribute-name="PortalAuthorizationManagerFactory"
 proxy-type="attribute">portal:service=PortalAuthorizationManagerFactory</depends>
 <depends
 optional-attribute-name="AuthorizationDomainRegistry"
 proxy-type="attribute">portal:service=AuthorizationDomainRegistry</depends>
 <depends
 optional-attribute-name="PortalEventListenerRegistry"
 proxy-type="attribute">portal:service=ListenerRegistry</depends>
 <attribute name="SessionFactoryJNDIName">java:/portal/PortalObjectSessionFactory</attribute>
 <!--attribute name="CacheNaturalId">true</attribute-->
 </mbean>