Getting Started Jar Version Incompatility

[freemarket]

Hi,

I'm following the getting started

http://www.jboss.org/jsfunit/gettingstarted.html

and having a collision apparently between the version of aspectj that cactus is pulling in (1.2.1) vs. the version that we want to use (1.5.4 or 1.6.1).

The jars in WEB-INF/lib are as follows:

1 total 59925
2 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 371142 Oct 1 09:19 CRDBJavaServerCommon-1197.jar
3 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 439 Oct 1 09:19 CRDBXMLExternal-1197.jar
4 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 127614 Oct 1 09:19 CRDBXMLServer-1197.jar
5 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 168388 Oct 1 09:19 Concurrent-1197.jar
6 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 2162 Oct 1 09:19 CrystalCommon-1197.jar
7 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 69587 Oct 1 09:19 CrystalContentModels-1197.jar
8 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 82468 Oct 1 09:19 CrystalDatabaseConnectors-1197.jar
9 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 651313 Oct 1 09:19 CrystalExporters-1197.jar
10 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 41698 Oct 1 09:19 CrystalExportingBase-1197.jar
11 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 597428 Oct 1 09:19 CrystalFormulas-1197.jar
12 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 320180 Oct 1 09:19 CrystalQueryEngine-1197.jar
13 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 2469655 Oct 1 09:19 CrystalReportEngine-1197.jar
14 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 439743 Oct 1 09:19 CrystalReportingCommon-1197.jar
15 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 248368 Oct 1 09:19 MetafileRenderer-1197.jar
16 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 286094 Oct 1 09:19 ReportPrinter-1197.jar
17 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 816947 Oct 1 09:19 ReportViewer-1197.jar
18 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 21921 Oct 1 09:19 Serialization-1197.jar
19 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 3777 Oct 1 09:19 URIUtil-1197.jar
20 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 544682 Feb 11 2008 acegi-security-1.0.6.jar
21 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 14075 Mar 6 2008 acegijsf-1.1.2.jar
22 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 63018 May 6 2008 activation-1.1.jar
23 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 1034049 Mar 6 2008 ant-1.6.5.jar
24 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 443432 Mar 6 2008 antlr-2.7.6.jar
25 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 26361 Mar 6 2008 asm-1.5.3.jar
26 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 16757 Mar 6 2008 asm-attrs-1.5.3.jar
27 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 41534 Nov 26 10:52 aspectjrt-1.2.1.jar
28 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 114926 Aug 25 13:19 aspectjrt-1.6.1.jar
29 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 8958838 Aug 25 13:19 aspectjtools-1.6.1.jar
30 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 1567728 Dec 1 13:54 aspectjweaver-1.6.1.jar
31 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 63966 Mar 6 2008 avalon-framework-4.1.3.jar
32 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 331716 Jun 27 11:38 backport-util-concurrent-3.1.jar
33 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 490136 Mar 6 2008 c3p0-0.9.0.4.jar
34 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 259182 Oct 31 11:20 cactus-13-1.7.1.jar
35 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 180327 Oct 31 11:20 cactus-ant-13-1.7.1.jar
36 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 359270 Oct 31 11:20 cargo-0.5.jar
37 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 1836822 Oct 1 09:19 cecore-1197.jar
38 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 209377 Oct 1 09:19 celib-1197.jar
39 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 282338 Mar 6 2008 cglib-2.1_3.jar
40 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 188671 Mar 6 2008 commons-beanutils-1.7.0.jar
41 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 168760 Oct 1 09:18 commons-beanutils-core-1.7.0.jar
42 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 46725 Mar 6 2008 commons-codec-1.3.jar
43 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 559366 Mar 6 2008 commons-collections-3.1.jar
44 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 163822 Oct 1 09:18 commons-configuration-1.2.jar
45 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 168446 Mar 6 2008 commons-digester-1.6.jar
46 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 76685 Oct 1 09:18 commons-discovery-0.4.jar
47 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 112341 Mar 6 2008 commons-el-1.0.jar
48 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 22379 Mar 6 2008 commons-fileupload-1.0.jar
49 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 305001 Oct 31 11:20 commons-httpclient-3.1.jar
50 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 109043 Oct 23 09:08 commons-io-1.4.jar
51 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 207723 Mar 6 2008 commons-lang-2.1.jar
52 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 52915 Mar 6 2008 commons-logging-1.1.jar
53 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 26202 Oct 1 09:18 commons-logging-api-1.0.4.jar
54 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 174535 Mar 6 2008 commons-math-1.1.jar
55 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 138956 Mar 6 2008 commons-validator-1.3.1.jar
56 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 16010 Dec 1 14:29 cre-aspects-1.0.jar
57 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 7285 Dec 1 14:29 cre-commons-1.0.jar
58 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 178353 Dec 1 14:30 cre-configuration-1.0.jar
59 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 106127 Dec 1 14:29 cre-dao-1.0.jar
60 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 721489 Dec 1 14:30 cre-dataupload-1.0.jar
61 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 378580 Dec 1 14:29 cre-entities-1.0.jar
62 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 12305 Dec 1 14:30 cre-manager-1.0.jar
63 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 447131 Dec 1 14:30 cre-reports-1.0.jar
64 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 34519 Dec 1 14:29 cre-rules-1.0.jar
65 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 11706 Dec 1 14:30 cre-scoringservice-1.0.jar
66 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 38294 Dec 1 14:30 cre-security-1.0.jar
67 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 14442 Dec 1 14:30 cre-workflow-1.0.jar
68 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 253950 Oct 31 11:20 cssparser-0.9.5.jar
69 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 313898 Mar 6 2008 dom4j-1.6.1.jar
70 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 505805 Mar 18 2008 dwr-2.0.2.jar
71 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 1985391 Oct 1 09:19 ebus405-1197.jar
72 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 242693 Jun 27 11:38 ehcache-1.4.0.jar
73 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 36962 Mar 6 2008 facestrace-0.8.1.jar
74 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 2198080 Oct 16 13:19 hibernate-3.2.1.ga.jar
75 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 265130 Feb 11 2008 hibernate-annotations-3.3.0.ga.jar
76 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 66426 Feb 11 2008 hibernate-commons-annotations-3.3.0.ga.jar
77 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 2266278 Oct 16 13:12 hibernate-core-3.3.0.GA.jar
78 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 649747 Oct 31 11:20 htmlunit-2.2.jar
79 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 558115 Oct 31 11:20 htmlunit-core-js-2.2.jar
80 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 3233439 Oct 1 17:18 icu4j-1197.jar
81 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 89967 May 6 2008 jaxb-api-2.1.jar
82 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 88562 Oct 31 11:21 jboss-jsfunit-analysis-1.0.0.Beta3.jar
83 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 13022 Oct 31 11:21 jboss-jsfunit-ant-1.0.0.Beta3.jar
84 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 68709 Oct 31 11:20 jboss-jsfunit-core-1.0.0.Beta3.jar
85 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 16989 Oct 31 11:21 jboss-jsfunit-richfaces-1.0.0.Beta3.jar
86 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 214624 Mar 7 2008 jep-3.2.0.jar
87 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 253824 Oct 1 09:19 jrcadapter-1197.jar
88 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 13234 Oct 1 09:19 jrcerom-1197.jar
89 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 756883 Oct 31 11:20 js-1.7R1.jar
90 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 300771 Apr 17 2008 jsf-facelets-1.1.14.jar
91 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 50493 Mar 6 2008 jsp-api-2.0.jar
92 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 8277 Jun 27 11:38 jsr107cache-1.0.jar
93 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 13236 Oct 16 13:12 jta-1.1.jar
94 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 120699 Oct 31 11:21 juel-2.1.0.jar
95 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 121070 Mar 6 2008 junit-3.8.1.jar
96 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 56890 Oct 1 09:19 keycodeDecoder-1197.jar
97 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 72150 Mar 6 2008 logkit-1.0.1.jar
98 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 115784 Oct 31 11:20 nekohtml-1.9.8.jar
99 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 65261 Mar 6 2008 oro-2.0.8.jar
100 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 52114 Mar 6 2008 persistence-api-1.0.jar
101 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 2073 Jun 17 13:51 phaseTracker-unknown.jar
102 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 964285 Aug 6 11:53 poi-3.0.2-FINAL.jar
103 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 96093 Oct 1 09:19 pullparser-1197.jar
104 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 524116 Oct 1 09:19 rasapp-1197.jar
105 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 965649 Oct 1 09:19 rascore-1197.jar
106 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 168454 Oct 16 13:24 richfaces-api-3.2.2.GA.jar
107 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 1494439 Oct 16 13:24 richfaces-impl-3.2.2.GA.jar
108 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 2525798 Oct 16 13:24 richfaces-ui-3.2.2.GA.jar
109 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 90701 Oct 1 09:19 rpoifs-1197.jar
110 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 15808 Oct 31 11:20 sac-1.3.jar
111 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 332055 May 6 2008 sjsxp-1.0.1.jar
112 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 15345 Feb 13 2008 slf4j-api-1.4.3.jar
113 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 7449 Oct 16 13:25 slf4j-simple-1.4.3.jar
114 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 2838649 Oct 16 13:14 spring-2.5.jar
115 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 161270 Feb 11 2008 spring-aop-1.2.9.jar
116 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 233138 Feb 11 2008 spring-beans-1.2.9.jar
117 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 110531 Feb 11 2008 spring-context-1.2.9.jar
118 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 126101 Feb 11 2008 spring-core-1.2.9.jar
119 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 95425 Feb 11 2008 spring-dao-1.2.9.jar
120 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 187036 Feb 11 2008 spring-jdbc-1.2.9.jar
121 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 141473 Feb 11 2008 spring-remoting-1.2.9.jar
122 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 166145 Feb 11 2008 spring-support-1.2.9.jar
123 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 26514 Mar 6 2008 stax-api-1.0.1.jar
124 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 26310 Oct 16 13:24 stax-api-1.0.jar
125 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 3755 Mar 6 2008 tag-handlers-0.9.jar
126 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 2941389 Feb 11 2008 tomahawk-1.1.6.jar
127 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 2730442 Oct 1 09:19 xalan-2.7.0.jar
128 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 895924 Mar 6 2008 xercesImpl-2.4.0.jar
129 -rwx------ 1 henry_katz mkpasswd 109318 Sep 4 09:27 xml-apis-1.0.b2.jar

This all boils down to spring 2.5 being unable to load an aspectj method:

org.springframework.beans.factory.BeanCreationException: Error creating bean with name 'logoutFilter' defined in class path resource [spring-cre-web.xml]: Cannot resolve reference to bean 'rememberMeServices' while setting constructor argument with key [0]; nested exception is org.springframework.beans.factory.BeanCreationException: Error creating bean with name 'rememberMeServices' defined in class path resource [spring-cre-web.xml]: Cannot resolve reference to bean 'userDetailsService' while setting bean property 'userDetailsService'; nested exception is org.springframework.beans.factory.BeanCreationException: Error creating bean with name 'userDetailsService' defined in class path resource [spring-cre-security.xml]: Cannot resolve reference to bean 'securityManager' while setting constructor argument; nested exception is org.springframework.beans.factory.BeanCreationException: Error creating bean with name 'securityManager' defined in class path resource [spring-cre-security.xml]: Cannot resolve reference to bean 'membershipDao' while setting constructor argument; nested exception is org.springframework.beans.factory.BeanCreationException: Error creating bean with name 'membershipDao' defined in class path resource [spring-cre-dao.xml]: Cannot resolve reference to bean 'hibernateTemplate' while setting bean property 'hibernateTemplate'; nested exception is org.springframework.beans.factory.BeanCreationException: Error creating bean with name 'hibernateTemplate' defined in class path resource [spring-cre-dao.xml]: Cannot resolve reference to bean 'sessionFactory' while setting bean property 'sessionFactory'; nested exception is org.springframework.beans.factory.BeanCreationException: Error creating bean with name 'sessionFactory' defined in class path resource [spring-cre-dao.xml]: Invocation of init method failed; nested exception is java.lang.NoSuchMethodError: org.aspectj.runtime.reflect.Factory.makeMethodSig(Ljava/lang/String;Ljava/lang/String;Ljava/lang/String;Ljava/lang/String;Ljava/lang/String;Ljava/lang/String;Ljava/lang/String;)Lorg/aspectj/lang/reflect/MethodSignature;


Can cactus use the more recent aspectj as per above?

Thanks,
Henry

[ssilvert]

I'm not sure, but my guess is that the newer aspectj should work.

You could ask your question on the Cactus mailing list to be sure. When you do, just make it clear that we are still using Cactus 1.7.1. It's on my todo list to upgrade JSFUnit to use Cactus 1.8.0, but I haven't done it yet.

Stan

[freemarket]

Stan,

Thanks for quick reply. My initial exclusion of aspectj within the cactus dependency was successful in removing aspectj v. 1.2.1. Have some more
issues to identify for followup posts.

Will scour the cactus archives as well.

Regards,
Henry