2 Replies Latest reply on Jun 26, 2013 12:49 AM by Neeta L

    Pros and Cons of Teiid development to implement data security

    Neeta L Newbie

      I want to evalaute Teiid implementation based on different parameters.

       

      My scneario is

      - Create VDB to point to Oracle and SQL Server (Either 2 seperate VDBs or one multi-source VDB). User will be connected any source at a time

      - Develop procedures on this VDB to define the security policies (row level securities - to obtain the data based on some inout paarameter by joining few tables)

      - Why Teiid - Same procedures can be used for both the data sources since they are created on VDB

       

      Can some one give me more details or their views on following points

       

      - Pros and Cons of using Teiid

      - Performance (If huge amount of data is rerieved by joining multiple tables. Transaction can be Select/Insert/Update etc)

      - Maintainability

      - Scalability

      - Robustness

      - Teiid Support provided by community

       

      Please help to understand above points

       

      Thanks in advance

       

      Neeta

        • 1. Re: Pros and Cons of Teiid development to implement data security
          Ramesh Reddy Master

          Neeta,

           

          Lot of what you are asking is for you to determine if they are acceptable for you and your organization based on your usecases and SLAs. What acceptable for one may not acceptable for other. Let me briefly touch some topics here

          - Pros and Cons of using Teiid

          Data Virtualization, the space the Teiid is in solves many issues. There are books written on this topic why and what benefits DV provides. It provides transparency from sources, integration of disparate sources, creation canonical view models, creation enterprise data dictionary, easy creation of data services to name a few. On top of it, add any number Teiid specific features like data security

          - Performance (If huge amount of data is rerieved by joining multiple tables. Transaction can be Select/Insert/Update etc)

          Lot of this depends upon the type of sources, latency and size of the data they are bringing to the JOIN to begin with. These are external to Teiid which it does not have any control on. Teiid has best  query optimization engine in this space (even compared to commercial entities in this space). It is has excellent buffering technologies to handle millions of rows efficiently. Teiid does rule and cost based optimizations such that it generates optimal query to sources. These are some of credits Teiid earned from our customers over 13 years of development in this space. See Teiid history on the website.

           

          - Maintainability

          Did you see the Teiid release schedule over past years and how we have been continually adding the new features? Teiid goes through time boxed released every 3 months. Teiid is basis of Redhat's Data Services Platform, where they provide support and services and patches to released products.

           

          - Scalability

          There is reason Teiid is built on using JBoss AS. It is an Enterprise JEE Application Server used by thousands of corporations around the world. It provides best of technologies in things such as clustering, transactions, JCA etc which matter to Teiid most in providing such scalability. Teiid provides load balancing and failover either using software only or using external load balancers. You can deploy as many Teiid nodes as you wish in your cluster to meet your usecase needs.

           

          - Teiid Support provided by community

          What you not been getting answers from community?

           

          No sane manager should approve to deploy their mission critical application solely based on community support. Community support is volunteering work, myself and any of other members do it when we have some time to spare and our willingness to help others in community and thus by promote Teiid project in general. You should NOT base support model based on the community support, if you need some SLAs. If this is your pet application running on your own machine that nobody care then that is fine.

           

          This is where Red Hat fills the gap. Red Hat can provide you support and services based on your enterprise requirements that community falls short of. When you run into a production issue in the middle of night, nobody from community will come your rescue, but Red Hat support team will. Community does NOT release any patches on bugs you find, Red Hat does. Community is always moving ahead with new versions, Red Hat provides a stable version of Teiid to work with. These are just to name few advantages of buying support. Obviously that comes at a cost, if interested contact Red Hat Sales.

           

          Hope these answers some of your concerns.

           

          Ramesh..

          • 2. Re: Pros and Cons of Teiid development to implement data security
            Neeta L Newbie

            Thanks Ramesh for response to all the queries.

            I have always been getting answers from the community for all my queries.

             

            I am thankful to entire community for all their support

             

            Thanks,

            Neeta