2 Replies Latest reply: May 26, 2011 6:41 AM by paul_m RSS

    getRollbackOnly() behaving strangely with inheritance in JBoss 6

    paul_m Newbie

      The following issue shows up with jboss-6.0.0.Final but works as I'd expect with jboss-5.1.0.GA.  Also, although I've not tested this extensively, I've only been aware of this problem when using EJB3 annotations.


      The EJB spec' seems pretty clear that EJBContext.getRollbackOnly() should throw java.lang.IllegalStateException if a bean's TransactionAttribute is 'NOT_SUPPORTED'.


      I have a base class with a method that uses getRollbackOnly().  In this example hasTxn() simply uses getRollbackOnly() to determine whether the method is called in the context of a container-managed transaction:


      import javax.annotation.Resource;
      import javax.ejb.SessionContext;
      public class TxnTestSSBBase
          @Resource SessionContext ctx;
          public boolean hasTxn()
                  return true;
              catch (IllegalStateException e)
                  return false;



      I then have an EJB (in this example a Stateless Session Bean) that extends the base class and implements a remote interface with the hasTxn() method.  Note that the bean's TransactionAttribute is NOT_SUPPORTED, and that the hasTxn() method in the sub-class (TxnTestSSB) is currently commented out so the super-class's implementation is called directly.


      import javax.ejb.Stateless;
      import javax.ejb.TransactionAttribute;
      import javax.ejb.TransactionAttributeType;
      import javax.ejb.TransactionManagement;
      import javax.ejb.TransactionManagementType;
      public class TxnTestSSB extends TxnTestSSBBase implements TxnTestSSBRemote
          public boolean hasTxn()
              return super.hasTxn();



      Deployed in JBoss 5.1 hasTxn() returns 'false' which is what I'd expect.  But if I deploy it in JBoss 6.0 hasTxn() returns 'true' - i.e. getRollbackOnly() completes without throwing an IllegalStateException in spite of the NOT_SUPPORTED TransactionAttribute.


      Interestingly, if I implement hasTxn() in TxnTestSSB, even if the implementation simply calls the super class (i.e. uncomment the commented-out code shown above), it correctly returns 'false' in JBoss 6.0.


      Am I missing something here?  Is this a known bug?  I've searched around a little, but maybe the underlying issue is broader than getRollbackOnly()/setRollbackOnly() and so I've missed it, not knowing quite what to search on?


      Thanks for any help anyone can provide,