5 Replies Latest reply on Nov 14, 2002 2:39 PM by Dan Desch

    Transactions and rollbacks or commits

    Dan Desch Newbie

      How do I manage a transaction within a bean? I have an EJB bean with all its various methods. One of these is a setDetail(ValueBean) method, where a value bean that holds the value of the various fields from the database is passed into the ejb bean. The fields from the value bean are each used as the argument to the abstract setter methods in the ejb bean. For example:


      pretty standard stuff I think.

      Let me change the scenario slightly and get to my point. Consider this code snippet:

      if (!businessRuleObserved())
      {force a rollback}


      So, my question is this: what if in the middle of this, say after the setField1() call, I want to put some logic that checks to see if some business rule has been maintained, and in the event that the rule has been violated, force a rollback to occur? Is this possible? I have a vague idea that there is something out there called a UserTransaction that might assist in this, but haven't a clue about the details of using it. Is there a better way?

        • 1. Re: Transactions and rollbacks or commits
          Jeremy Boynes Newbie

          An Entity bean cannot use UserTransaction - however, it can force a rollback by calling setRollbackOnly() on the EJBContext which may work in your case.

          Alternatively you could consider doing the check before modifying the bean's state with the first call and give the caller more choice about what happens to the transaction.

          • 2. Re: Transactions and rollbacks or commits
            Dan Desch Newbie

            Thanks for your reply.

            How does one gain access to the EJBContext?

            Just for the sake of explanation: I'd prefer to trigger the rollback from within the entity bean after the bean's state has been modified, rather than before (as you suggest), because the business logic requirement can not be tested with 100% certainty until after the modification occurs.

            • 3. Re: Transactions and rollbacks or commits
              Dan Desch Newbie

              Doh! Never mind about the EJBContext access question--I see it.

              Thanks again.

              • 4. Re: Transactions and rollbacks or commits
                Jeremy Boynes Newbie

                It's passed by the container in setEntityContext(ctx).

                Setting the txn to rollback only is pretty traumatic - it causes the container to rollback all RM's (e.g. DBs), dump state for all beans involved and results in a TxnRollbackEx at the client.

                If you can figure out how to perform the test without modifying state, you can throw an application exception. This has the advantage of telling the client exactly what the problem was, and without the side-effects in the container.

                Either approach works - they just have different consequences.

                • 5. Re: Transactions and rollbacks or commits
                  Dan Desch Newbie

                  I suppose I could perform the test prior to modifying the state provided I could lock the state of the RM so that it doesn't change between test and update.

                  Sheesh, all this abstract talk gives me a headache--let me translate into concrete terms.

                  The update I am performing is to the account number field of a General Ledger accounts table. The account number field is not a key field, but does have some key like characteristics, specifically, its value should be unique, hence the test. If I could perform the test prior to any update, AND be sure that no other updater can jump in and store the same account number value before I get to do my update, then that would be fine. Since I don't know how to (or if it is even possible to) lock the database from within the confines of the bean, I chose the route of doing the update, then checking to see if it resulted in duplicate account numbers and if so, rolling back the update.

                  If you know a technique for establishing a lock, I'd be very interested to see it.

                  Again, thanks for your replies.