Thanks,

but as we know the default execute for <a4j:ajax is @this not @form .

Thank, it is working now but in the demo showcase they are not use the a4j:ajax and the validation is working and fireing without any problem

http://showcase.richfaces.org/richfaces/component-sample.jsf?demo=clientValidation&sample=jsr303&skin=blueSky

But all my validation is client side not customized read this : https://community.jboss.org/message/822491#822491

@Entity(name="DW_OUT_SOURCED")

@Table(name="DW_OUT_SOURCED")

@TableGenerator(name = "outsourcedGenerator", table = "DW_SEQUENCE", schema = "DIWAN", pkColumnName = "SEQ_NAME", valueColumnName = "SEQ_VALUE", pkColumnValue = "OUT_SOURCED_SEQUENCE", allocationSize = 1, initialValue = 0)

public class OutsourcedBean extends BaseBean{

          @Id

          @GeneratedValue(strategy = GenerationType.TABLE, generator="outsourcedGenerator")

          @Column(name="ID")

          private int Id;

          @NotEmpty(message="{GEN_REQUIRED}" , groups={AddValidationGroup.class , EditValidationGroup.class,ManageValidationGroup.class})

          @JoinColumn(name="TYPE_ID",referencedColumnName="ID",nullable=false)

          @ManyToOne

          private ChildLKPBean type;

          @NotEmpty(message="{GEN_REQUIRED}" , groups={AddValidationGroup.class , EditValidationGroup.class})

          @Column(name="NAME_AR",length=100, nullable = false,unique = true)

          private String nameAr;

          @NotEmpty(message="{GEN_REQUIRED}" , groups={AddValidationGroup.class , EditValidationGroup.class})

          @Column(name="NAME_EN",length=100, nullable = false,unique = true)

          private String nameEn;

          @Column(name="PERSON_NAME",length=200)

          private String personName;

          @Column(name="PHONE_NUMBER",length=20)

          private String phoneNumber;

          @Column(name="FAX_NUMBER",length=20)

          private String faxNumber;

          @Column(name="MOBILE_NUMBER",length=20)

          private String mobileNumber;

          @Column(name="POBOX",length=200)

          private String pobox;

          @Column(name="EMAIL_ADDRESS",length=200)

          @Email(message="{GEN_EMAIL_FORMAT_IS_NOT_CORRECT}",groups={AddValidationGroup.class , EditValidationGroup.class})

          private String emailAddress;

          @Column(name="NOTE",length=200)

          private String note;

          @Column(name="ORDER_ID",length=10)

          private int order;

Dear Brian

it solved the disappear problem when i change the a4j:ajax execute to @form but this soluation cuase another problem which is when there is another filed validation fail the current field value dose not change becuase the form validation falid

Regards

Wish