bug when a4j:include and rich:tab?

[liuliu]

I have a template:leftcenterright.xhtml

 <a4j:outputPanel layout="block" id="detailFilterDiv" >
 <ui:insert name="left">
 </ui:insert>
 </a4j:outputPanel>

 <a4j:outputPanel layout="block" id="detailRestoreDiv" >
 <ui:insert name="menu">
 </ui:insert>
 </a4j:outputPanel>

 <a4j:outputPanel layout="block" id="detailResultDiv" >
 <ui:insert name="right">
 </ui:insert>
 </a4j:outputPanel>

tab1.xhtml,tab2.xhtml,tab3.xhtml use this template.

 <rich:tabPanel switchType="ajax" >
 <rich:tab id="tab1" label="tab1" >
 <a4j:include viewId="/tab1.xhtml" />
 </rich:tab>
 <rich:tab id="tab2" label="tab2" >
 <a4j:include viewId="/tab2.xhtml" />
 </rich:tab>
 <rich:tab id="tab3" label="tab3" >
 <a4j:include viewId="/tab3.xhtml" />
 </rich:tab>
 </rich:tabPanel>

when use a4j:include, i have not error duplicate id for detailFilterDiv,detailRestoreDiv and detailResultDiv.(i got a error when use ui:include)

the problem is in one of 3 tab page, if i demand to refresh detailResultDiv, the content in 3 tab pages is refreshed. all getter is called. Is it normal?

[sergeysmirnov]

are you using RichFaces 3.0.0 or 3.0.1 snapshot (the same question about Ajax4jsf)?

[liuliu]

i'm using vajax4jsf 1.1.1 snapshot and richfaces-3.0.1 snapshot. but i'm not sure they are the latest. i have downloaded them for some weeks.

[ilya_shaikovsky]

What is the facelets version you've used? Right now I'm able to use ui:include inside tabs.

My Env:
RF and A4j current SNAPSHOTS
JSF 1.2_04
Facelets 1.1.12

[liuliu]

myfaces 1.1.5
facelet 1.1.12

[liuliu]

hi,

i found where comes the problem, it is because of the position of form, but i dont know why.

when i place only one h:form around the rich:tabpanel, or a h:form for a a4j:include. there is no problem.

<h:form>
<rich:tabPanel switchType="ajax" >
 <rich:tab id="tab1" label="tab1" >
 <a4j:include viewId="/tab1.xhtml" />
 </rich:tab>
 <rich:tab id="tab2" label="tab2" >
 <a4j:include viewId="/tab2.xhtml" />
 </rich:tab>
 <rich:tab id="tab3" label="tab3" >
 <a4j:include viewId="/tab3.xhtml" />
 </rich:tab>
 </rich:tabPanel>
</h:form>

or

<rich:tabPanel switchType="ajax" >
 <rich:tab id="tab1" label="tab1" >
 <h:form>
 <a4j:include viewId="/tab1.xhtml" />
 </h:form>
 </rich:tab>
 <rich:tab id="tab2" label="tab2" >
 <h:form>
 <a4j:include viewId="/tab2.xhtml" />
 </h:form>
 </rich:tab>
 <rich:tab id="tab3" label="tab3" >
 <h:form>
 <a4j:include viewId="/tab3.xhtml" />
 </h:form>
 </rich:tab>
 </rich:tabPanel>

but if the form is in the file included, the problem appears.

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1"?>

<ui:composition template="/template/leftcenterright.xhtml"
 xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"
 xmlns:ui="http://java.sun.com/jsf/facelets"
 xmlns:h="http://java.sun.com/jsf/html"
 xmlns:f="http://java.sun.com/jsf/core" >
<ui:define name="left">
 <h:form>
 <h:inputText id="aa" value="#{bean.prop1}" />
 </h:form>
</ui:define>
</ui:composition>

Any explanation? maybe the a4j forgets the id added by a4j:include when rebuilding the component tree?

thanks