JBoss WS-Eventing vs JMS-Topic

[sbutt]

Hi there,
I'm planning to implement a data-mining/analysis application (using WS-Eventing framework), which would get some data from a number of third party providers and analyse it.

I'm assuming my analysis application would be an Event Consumer (sink) WS-Client, which would subscribe to Event Producer(source), responsible for third party data providers? Do you think my understanding is correct at this stage?

Actually, my scenario is that I have a number of clients to whom we're sending some requests and in return getting some response. So in nut-shell what i'm looking for is a kind of analysis application, through which I can monitor what was sent to which client and what I got in response(success, error, warning etc etc).

So do you think that with the help of WS-Eventing framework I can take care of the above scenario?

Secondly, I have also read about JMS-Notification framework similarly based upon Producer-Subscriber design pattern. So can anybody suggest, which one is more robust and beneficial over the other?

One good reason I can think about WS-Eventing framework is that the communication is going to be in the form of SOAP, so Event-Consumer endpoint can be implemented in any language be it php, c#, asp etc etc.

In-case of JMS-Notification, it is going to be Java dependent. Is this assumption true and what other reasons there can be to give preference to WS-Eventing over JMS-Notification?

Thanks.

[sbutt]

Sorry for the type in my previous message, from JMS-Notification i meant JMS-Topic framework.

"sbutt" wrote:
Hi there,
I'm planning to implement a data-mining/analysis application (using WS-Eventing framework), which would get some data from a number of third party providers and analyse it.

I'm assuming my analysis application would be an Event Consumer (sink) WS-Client, which would subscribe to Event Producer(source), responsible for third party data providers? Do you think my understanding is correct at this stage?

Actually, my scenario is that I have a number of clients to whom we're sending some requests and in return getting some response. So in nut-shell what i'm looking for is a kind of analysis application, through which I can monitor what was sent to which client and what I got in response(success, error, warning etc etc).

So do you think that with the help of WS-Eventing framework I can take care of the above scenario?

Secondly, I have also read about JMS-Notification framework similarly based upon Producer-Subscriber design pattern. So can anybody suggest, which one is more robust and beneficial over the other?

One good reason I can think about WS-Eventing framework is that the communication is going to be in the form of SOAP, so Event-Consumer endpoint can be implemented in any language be it php, c#, asp etc etc.

In-case of JMS-Notification, it is going to be Java dependent. Is this assumption true and what other reasons there can be to give preference to WS-Eventing over JMS-Notification?

Thanks.