s:link id assignment not working as expected Seam 2 CR1

[nathandennis]

it would seem that s:link id assignment is still not working as expected Seam 2 CR1.
i first discovered the problem in 2 beta version download from csv around 081707. i found one tread that was discussing a simular issue with commandLink and JIRA issue said it was fixed for 2 CR1... so i upgraded.... but still having the same problem.

the problem is that the id for the s:link within a column of a dynamic table that contains multiple rows is a duplicate. if i try to pass the id a unique value using EL it returns a null... end result is my page works,, but doesnt validate... a real pain for us perfectionist.....
here an example of some code...

 <rich:dataTable var="blogEntry"
 value="#{bloggerList.resultList}"
 rendered="#{not empty bloggerList.resultList}"
 style=" border-right-width: 0px;
 border-bottom-width: 0px;
 border-left-width: 0px;
 border-top-width: 0px;">
 <rich:column valign="top" id="a#{blogEntry.id}">
 <div class="blogEntry" align="left">
 <h3>#{blogEntry.title}</h3>
 #{blogEntry.blog}
 <s:link view="/#{empty from ? 'Blog' : from}.xhtml"
 value="More">
 <f:param name="bloggerId"
 value="#{blogEntry.id}"/>
 </s:link>
 <p>
 [Posted on

 #{blogEntry.listdate}]
 </p>
 </div>
 <div style="padding-top:5px;">
 <hr align="left" width="500"/>
 </div>
 </rich:column>
 </rich:dataTable>

if im missing something i apologize,,,, but im pretty sure this worked in seam 1.2.1

any enlightenment would be greatly appreciated.

[nathandennis]

this has the desired result..... but to go back and change this is large projects is going to be a rough,,, and im going to loose the ability to alter the extension easily.

 <h:outputLink value="/#{empty from ? 'Blog' : from}.seam"
 >More
 <s:conversationId />
 <f:param name="bloggerId"
 value="#{blogEntry.id}"/>
 </h:outputLink>

[pmuir]

http://jira.jboss.com/jira/browse/JBSEAM-1947 - sorry about that (fixed in CVS)

[nathandennis]

thanks for the quick response and resolution.

you guys keep up the good work