SE, Qualifiers and Event not working as expected

[pieter.martin]

Hi,

I am using WELD trunk and running a standalone se app.

When I inject a qualified event the observers fire regardless of whether observe methods qualifiers.

     @Inject @EventQualifier1
     private Event<EventTest> eventTest;     
     
     public void start(@Observes ContainerInitialized event) {
          logger.info("WeldTest.start");
          
          eventTest.fire(new EventTest());
          
          logger.info("shutting producer down");
          shutdownManager.shutdown();          
     }
     
     public void observeEventTest(@Observes @EventQualifier2 EventTest eventTest) {
          logger.info("WeldTest.observeEventTest");
     }

The injected event is qualified with @EventQualifier1 and the observe method with @EventQualifier2, yet the observe method still fires. In fact the observe method's qualifiers make no difference, it always fires.

Is this a bug?

Thanks
Pieter

[nickarls]

As long as your qualifier annotations really are qualifiers, observeEventTest shouldn't fire. Could you check the JIRA if it's a known bug and file a new one if it's not?

[pieter.martin]

Jira has WELD-384 which looks similar.

[pmuir]

This is working in trunk, see http://fisheye.jboss.org/changelog/weld/?cs=5690 :-)

Double check you have trunk I think ;-)

[pieter.martin]

Pulled the latest trunk and had a look at that code. It does not look to me that that test case is working even though it passes.

The method in Foo

   public void start(@Observes ContainerInitialized event, ShutdownManager shutdownManager)
   {
      eventTest.fire(new Bar());
   }

does not execute at all. Seeing as Foo.isObservedEventTest() is false to start with assert !Foo.isObservedEventTest(); passes in EventsTest.

It looks like

WeldContainer weld = new Weld().initialize();

does not start Weld up properly.

I have been using

org.jboss.weld.environment.se.StartMain.main(args)

to start up Weld and then the @Observes ContainerInitialized event fires.

Cheers
Pieter

[pmuir]

Good point! I manually fired the ContainerInitialized event, and also verified that the container initialized event is called. All looks good - not sure what is up with your code - distill it to a test case and we can look.

[pieter.martin]

Ok thanks alls well, my qualifier annotation had @InterceptorBinding instead of @Qualifier which is kinda embarrassing.

Cheers
Pieter