Jboss 7.2.0.Final BUG in CDI Container ?

[suikast42]

Hi,

I spent my last three days to understand why hibernate throw

javax.persistence.PersistenceException: org.hibernate.PersistentObjectException: detached entity passed to persist: com.siemag.jpatest.backend.model.User

At first I thought I have a problem with my biderctional many-to-many relationship and play with that. The strange thing for me was that the test work two or three times then it crashes.

After deep debugging I find out that I get an detached object from my DAO ( EJB stateless).  This was Injected with @Inject. And that was the problem. If I change it to @EJB everything works as expected.

Injection happens here

See UserDAOHibernateTest:50

Expetion is thrown here:

See UserDAOHibernateTest:315

I read about that I can inject EJB beans with @Inject. And I did that in my test.

Is there a bug in Weld ?

Or if I use @Inject instead of @EJB must the dao inject other EJB with @Inject too ??

You can find the testapp at github.

[suikast42]

For clarification:

UserDAOHibernateTest.java


// If I use @Inject for userDAO then it can be happen that the user1 is detached ( this call is surrounded with a transaction)

line 315: User user1 = userDAO.getByName(userName1);

GenericHibernateDAO.java

line 52:    public T getByName(String name) {
        return (T) eDAO.getByName(getPersistentClass(), name);
    }

So if I use @Inject in my test then it can be happen that the result user1 and the result of getByName are different references:

For example:

eDAO returns user@FFFFF but user1 is user@AAAAA