Guess I should mention what I did for those that don't want to do a diff and figure it out.

Fixed a repeatable exception which can be caused by the following:
Go to the details for a download without an editorial, click Editor review.

The un-implemented method link was reachable by clicking on "comments" for a download with comments and then clicking on the little edit graphic. I added in all the needed methods to the module and stuff to the template and resouce file so that an admin can modify any rating/comment. I also made it so that the edit graphic link only appears for admins.

what do you want to do ? fix the download module bugs and submit new code ?

yep

Based on what was mentioned over at http://www.jboss.org/index.html?module=bb&op=viewtopic&t=53145 I found another bug(s).

My new update to the downloads modules is at http://www.ej4l.com/downloads.zip
If someone else could try it out that'd be great.

Things fixed/changed in this update:
1) Entering a ftp url causes a ClassCastException
2) Support was added to validate ftp urls
3) Support was added to allow ftp style urls with usernames and passwords

All updates to the downloads module are now in CVS so I'm removing the zip of my updates. Here's the log of the latest CVS update:

Implemented minor wording and layout changes.

Minor features added to fix bugs:

* Support was added to validate ftp urls
* Support was added to allow ftp style urls with usernames and passwords

Bugs fixed:

* Entering a ftp url causes a ClassCastException
* Deleting a rating(along with it's comment) doesn't recalculate the total
number of comments
* Deleting a rating doesn't recalculate the overall rating of a download
* A user creating or modifying their rating of a download to "--" will cause
an ArrayIndexOutOfBoundsException if they view the details for that download
* A user modifying their comment to nothing doesn't cause the total number of
comments to be updated for that download
* A user could rate a download to any number by typing in the correct url
* A user rating a comment to something other then 1 through 10 is sent back to
the main download page with no error message
* After an admin accepts or ignores the last download modification request,
presses "Return to modification rerquests" and then "Back" an error is displayed
* The "File link" portion of a users modification request is ignored if approved
* The admin's modification request page doesn't display the "File link" information
* The "Main Download Area" button was not display on the admin's modification
request page when there was no request
* The page layout was wrong when the admin had more then one download modification
request to view

Guess I was just happy to get commit rights :)